This post is in response and in protest of Chandigarh Administration and its Department of Environment. I will continue to put updates periodically unless the notification to ban plastic bags is either withdrawn by the Administration or is struck down by the courts. It is now my intention to fight the government on this online because I see this as a mega downgrade in my quality of life. All of those who are affected by this ban in any way are requested to use the contact me form (opens in a new window) so that we can formulate strategy to fight this ban. Regular posts will continue on this blog as usual.
A corrupt and inefficient administration can only make inefficient laws.
What is the quality of your government? It is a question that people often do not ask themselves. What exactly do you get in return for your tax rupee? If you are going to pay for the entire show, should you accept poor service from the government? Government is not funded by some magic fund, it extracts its pound of flesh. If it then passes laws that are basically inefficient the working of such administration requires greater scrutiny. I am a busy man and I have had no time yet to to ask the administration of chandigarh any direct questions. I am pondering about doing that later and the fact that my previous questions are still unanswered by the Department of Environment of Chandigarh Administration does not motivate me to demand answers from them directly at the moment. So I used the tools available to me and found some answers on my own.
- Why did my letter to the department of environment go unanswered?
Answer: Most likely because they have no system in place to answer questions of their constituents or the people they rule through e-mail. Apparently the Municipal Corporation of Chandigarh has spent thousands if not hundreds of thousands on computers, laptops, information technology equipment but has nothing in place to answer e-mails. This was made apparent by a news story I found here.
- How serious is the Chandigarh Administration and Municipal Corporation when it comes to planning and execution of various projects? What is their general track record?
- 300 Million Rupee Garbage Processing Plant : Doomed from Day 1. This project is basically non functional. The municipal government is responsible for its working. Just to make that clear. The Tribune story on that can be found here.
- Mechanical Sweeping Machines : Purchased for 30 Million Rupees these parking lot cleaning machines are supposed to clean our roads. These were supposed to be used at night time when there is no traffic but they are being deployed during full rush hour traffic. The people who purchased these machines apparently traveled all the way to Italy to inspect them when similar machines were available down a 3 hour train ride in Delhi! More on useless foreign trips of our corrupt and dishonest bureaucratic oligarchy type rulers later on in this post.
- Underpasses : Not one has been constructed! Although enough funds were spent in Belgium while investigating how to build them, where and how to even maintain them. Maintenance for non existing underpasses!
- Firefighting equipment : Apparently a ladder was purchased for 25.1 million Rupees from Finland which is never deployed for the fire department! The details of all these sordid purchases can be found here.
Answer :The more I searched the more disappointed I got. Apparently they have a whole media trail leading up to them that proves that they are basically excuse the term pissing away public wealth. It is so terrible that there is even no finesse even when it comes to covering up their tracks.
- Are the officers of the Administration squandering away public wealth?
Answer : Unfortunately yes. Between 2005-07, Krishna Mohan a former Home Secretary of the Administration spent an amazing Rs. 1.9 million, former Finance Secretary S.K. Sandhu spent almost a cool one million and junior officers like the Tourism Director for this disgusting and vile administration Vivek Atray spent Rs 1.6 million! So now you might ask what did they spent it all on. Foreign trips!!! They travelled business class or First Class. Stayed at the best hotels and even billed their theater tickets, entertainment expenses etc to the government. Details about their adventures in Europe and elsewhere can be found by clicking here, here and here.
So now you might ask me what does all of the above have to do with the ban on plastic bags. It is very simple. Lets just have a rough calculation of the money that was squandered away by our environment conscious administration on the topics we covered in this post alone. Here we go.
Chandigarh Administration’s Wasteful Expenditure Bill According to Odzer.Com
Projects that never paid off or took off
Garbage Disposal Plant : Rs. 300,000,000.00
Street Sweeping Machines : Rs. 30,000,000.00
Hydraulic Ladder : Rs. 25,100,000.00
Foreign trips made by various city officials with the Administration : Rs. 5,000,000.00
Grand TOTAL : Rs. 360,100,00.00 or around US$ 727,041.90
So now lets see what you can do with that kind of money? Can you buy a plant to recycle the whole cities plastic? Well one idea can be that you should use plastic as a construction material which is already being considered by Cochi in Kerala. The price tag around 25 million rupees. 5 million less than the non functional garbage processing unit we have in place right now! Even the Chinese seem to have been putting in plastic recycling plants a country that is notorious for its pollution. Beijing just put in one at the cost of US$ 37.5 million.The Chinese are aiming to recycle plastic back in to polyster though instead of using it as contruction material. In fact the plant being considered by Kochi is far cheaper and made in India! I am not even sure we need such a huge plant to recycle our plastic in this city. In fact I am not in to the business of running the government but even I can see that in the amount of money they have just thrown away in the last few years they could have effectively solved this city’s plastic problem effectively. They might even have had some surplus funds to educate people regarding not littering the streets and seperating their garbage! In fact I am going to do next week’s post on garbage seperation. So for now all I will say is that to me it is clear beyond the shadow of a doubt that the Chandigarh Administration and the Municipal government are guilty of a misinformation and a deception campaign. They had the means and the ability to solve environmental problems in another way except imposing this stupid ban that is leading to such agony.